tv The Rachel Maddow Show MSNBC April 19, 2011 12:00am-1:00am EDT
>> well, we have anecdotal information that some of them have expressed a lot of concern about the type of candidates that are being discussed to run against them, so it appears that they're worried. >> thank you very much for joining us tonight. >> thank you. >> you can have the last word online at our blog, the lastword.msnbc,.com. the conversation continues on twitter. the rachel maddow show is up next. >> thank you at home for staying with us for the next hour. happy patriot's day. patriots day means that if you live in massachusetts, your state taxes, i think, are not due today. they're due tomorrow because today is a holiday.
everybody else everywhere else in the country, today was the deadline for taxes, and tax day nowadays means tea parties. the tea party was supposed to stand for taxed, enough already. right? in between and in 2010 on tax day there were really big tea party rallies all across the country. two years ago in, say, olympia, washington, there were between 4,000 and 5,000 people rallying on tax day. last year they still had a pretty good number. they had about 3,000 people. this year the washington state tea party groups called for their third annual tax day tea party rally. would they get 4,000 or 5,000 people like they did two years ago? would they get 3,000 people like they did last year? no, they would not. they got 350 people. in the republican party stronghold of orange county, california, this was some of the coverage of the big tax day tea party protest there. >> amid a course of honking car horns, around a dozen tea party activists and a few anti-tea
party demonstrators converged on laguna beach on saturday to protest raising taxes and to bring awareness of their respective causes. >> a dozen. not counting the people in the bikinis. a teeth party rally in chicago, illinois, as well. they told chicago to expect thousands of tea party demonstrators. what chicago actually got was several hundred. they even had a presidential candidate at that one. they had herman cain, the pizza guy. he was one of four presidential hopefuls who headlined a big banner concorde, new hampshire, tea party on friday. the four presidential hopefuls were rick santorum, herman cain, buddy roamer, and tim pawlenty. all four appearing at the big tax day tea party thing in concorde, new hampshire, with four presidential candidates in new hampshire, they got 300 people to show up. to be fair, though, that may have had something to do with tim pawlenty being there. everything that mr. pawlenty
does these days seems to get very low attendance figures. mr. pawlenty also went to this tax day tea party in des moines, iowa. can you see the overwhelming crowd. the address day not standing room only crowd of about 300 people, generously speaking. remember sharon engel in nevada. she was favored to beat harry reid this past fall this and that hotly contested senate race. she hosted this rally in las vegas. about 250 people at its peak, and reportedly, the figures there dropped to about, well, around about 100 people by the time sharon angle started doing this. ♪ ♪ at least i know i'm free ♪ i won't forget the men who died ♪ ♪ who gave that right to me ♪ i proudly stand up >> she's good. about 150 people who had earlier been at the rally missed that.
down to a few dozen by the time she was singing. sharon angle, for all i ever said about ow this air, i never knew you were that good a singer. i'm sorry. even the tea party rallies that you would expect to be really big because of where they were and because of who was headlining them, even the things you -- the ones that you thought would turn out to be sort of thinking big bragging on the turnout events, they just didn't really get very many people. places like columbia, south carolina, for example. deep red south carolina. they had their newly elected sitting governor, nicki heyleaf speak and probably the most crowd-pleasing of all the likely republican presidential candidates, michelle bachman. the michelle bachman tea party rally attracted a grand total of, again, about 300 people. the same event two years ago reportedly attracted ten times that many people. where are they this year? what's going on? the tiny crowd sizes in all of these cities and state capitals this year when compared to what those same cities and state
capitals attracted from tea partiers in years past, it's all the more remarkable when you consider that last year and the year before in addition to much better attendance at all those rallies in the cities, all of those rallies in the cities in 2009 and 2010 were also competing for attendes with big tea party rallies in washington d.c. remember, in 2009 tens of thousands of tea partiers turned up in washington on tax day. in 2010 same deal. thousands and thousands of people descended on d.c. in addition to all the rallies in the state capitals. this year the last few national calls for tea partyers are getting very veshgs small crowds. they did not even try calling
for a national tax day tea party rally in d.c. this year. there just wasn't one. they didn't do it. they had very small turnout in all of the cities in the state capitals where they had rallies. they didn't have one in d.c. competing with them, and still, it just kind of fizzled. i think the writing has been on the wall for a while now about the strength of the tea party. last month there was supposed to be a big tea party convention down in tampa, florida. this is what that looked like. a convention that had 25 guest speakers, including congressman ron paul attracted, again, about 300 people. very large rooms. very large empty rooms full of no one. i'm not saying that the tea party has never been strong. it's always been a weak movement or that they never had political mojo, but judging by their public events, which is what we used to judge them by when we said they were strong, the tea party seems to have peaked. it seems to be over. someone tell the beltway press.
the beltway press says it's a hugely influential force. republicans are allowed to stake out policy positions and way to the right of where they might otherwise be because they supposedly have to answer to this ferocious big energized movement. democrats try to negotiate with them. those negotiations also shift further and further to the right. there's not much empirical evidence of the existence of this tea party thing as a big movement anymore. as long as nobody in washington reports on that or notices that, republicans in washington can still use the idea of the tea party as a means of pushing the debate as far right as they want to push it. the one tax day tea party event that seems to have gotten any crowd of any significant size this year was this weekend in madison, wisconsin. sarah palin spoke there on saturday. she stood at a podium that read "i am afp." that stands for americans for prosperity. sarah palin, i am americans for prosperity. americans for prosperity is the cook brothers funded group that organized this rally and that has supported the union stripping republicans in
wisconsin politics. according to reported estimates, the saturday madison rally drew a total of about 6,000 people, but there is an astericks on that figure that is larger than the figure itself which is that what seems to have inflated the sarah palin tea party event numbers to respectable size is a very large number of counter protesters. people who were not there to cheer on sarah palin and the tea party, but who were there to show their disagreement with both ms. palin and the tea party message. the local news station wmtv describes the core of tea partiers there to see sarah palin as being "flanked on all sides by union protesters." if you want to talk about political strength made manifest in the streets, then the story of 2011 is the story of the democratic base.
even if you wanted to erase history, right, even if you wanted to ignore what everybody said about the character of those in madison, even if you just decide to be generous that every one of those 6,000 people had turned out to cheer for sarah palin instead of cheering against her, even if that were true, put that 6,000 figure up against this. a massive rally held at the same location week after week after week in the last few months. 30,000 one weekend. 70,000 the next weekend. 100,000 the weekend after that. all in support of union rights. there's no great democratic party rallying those folks. this is the democratic base rallying themselves against the republicans. these crowds are there on policy, on principle. same thing in michigan where the state capitol in lancing saw its largest protests ever. pro-union protesters. there are protesters there against the republican approach to the budget there. same thing in columbus, ohio. big sustained protests week after week.
not, hey, show up here this one day. these rallies were day after day after day. in olympia, washington, which i cited as an example at the top here, where the tea party rally got 350 people this year. in olympia washington they look back on the glory days as when they got 4,000 or 5,000 people back in 2009, right? back in 20094,000 or 5,000 people. that's probably when they peaked. did it get any national coverage at all when 7,000 people turned out in olympia this month to protest union stripping and budget cuts? protesters turned out on the other side of the issues? i recognize that there's an institutional resistance to covering direct action protest movements, but if you are going to say the country and its politics have been transformed by one size protests in the streets and then you are going to completely ignore the other side's larger protests in the streets, there ought to at least be an explanation for that
inconsistency, you guys. and the explanation may be that republicans in washington have constantly cited the tea party as the constituency that they need to answer to. it's almost like they can't be held accountable for their own policy proposals. there are these angry right wing mobs in the streets that must be appeased. republicans use that as leverage. they use the existence and the supposed strength of the tea party movement as leverage for the policy positions that they want anyway. don't blame us. we have to answer for these -- we have to answer to these people in the streets. here's the thing, though. democrats could do that as well. democrats could do that and with better reason. there are more of the democratic base in the streets right now than the tea party even at its height. the democrats have not been doing that. why haven't they? republicans push every single numerical advantage they can. democrats give those advantages up regularly. case in point, who is in control of the u.s. senate right now? democrats, right? who has the democratic controlled senate allowed to be in charge of coming up with an approach to the deficit plan? i mean, in the house, right, it's republicans who are in charge, but what's the basis for the discussion in the house?
it's the paul ryan house republican budget plan. the republican budget plan because they're in control of that house. its first line written about today is where the president has failed, house republicans will lead. a deeply partisan approach in the house where republicans are in control of that side of the legislature. the senate, on the other side, that's controlled by democrats. so who is the senate having in charge of coming up with a plan on that side? they're having it done by a bipartisan group equally split between republicans and democrats. this gang of six. the democrats are in control of the senate, but they are not taking advantage of their numbers. just like they didn't during the health reform debate. remember that gang of six? just like they didn't during the 2008 battle over energy reform? remember that gang of ten? instead of using the fact that voters have given them a numerical advantage in that body, they are just seeding the democratic controlled body to an equally divided bipartisan gang. effectively giving up their advantage. right now in the streets republicans do not have an advantage, but they are still pressing an old one that they
maybe had a year ago. democrats, on the other hand, have an advantage in the streets right now, and they are not use it. they have one in the senate, and they are not using it. why not? joining us now is chris hayes, washington editor of "the nation" magazine and msnbc contributor. mr. hayes, nice to see you. >> great to see you as well. >> what do you think about the thesis that the existence of the tea party is used to change washington republicans' negotiating position? are those 12 people out at the beach in orange county this weekend, are they the mandate to kill medicare? >> they're terrifying. i think it's really -- you know, it's funny. as you were going through that opening, i have thought a lot about exactly this issue. david from, the conservative, has this line that he says all the time which really ring true to me. republicans fear their base, and democrats hate their base. i think there's -- the question of who the base is gets really tricky. let's say the activists.
right? the kinds of people that show up at a protest who are loud and vocal. it is absolutely true there's an age difference between the two sides and that the republicans show much -- elected republican leaders show much more fear of their activist core than democrats do, and democrats -- there's nothing they love more than the sort of internet term is hippie punching, right? it's sort of making a big show of how much they distance themselves from the left fringe, from their activist base, whereas republicans seem to do the opposite, right? they embrace it. i can't tell if this is cultural, if this is about the nature of the demographic poor, of what those activists' bases are. if it's some bizarre psychological process of formation. i've actually thought about whether if you go to law schools and, like, yale and you start to hate hippies or something. i don't know what it is, but it really is true.
there's like an asymmetry between the two sides. absolutely. >> that's why i connected this to the gang of six phenomenon because the gang of six phenomenon is democrats being presented with a numerical advantage in the senate and just giving it up, deciding not to use that to come up with a pure democratic approach to deficit reduction in the budget the way that the republicans are in the house, but instead saying, you know, we know we're in charge, but let's all work together. they did the same thing in health reform. they do the same thing over and over and over again in the senate while they are in charge of it and i just wonder if this is sort of the fact that this happens on the essentially ignoring tens of thousands of people in the streets in madison and ignoring their numerical advantage in the senate if this might explain something about the democratic brain and the not taking advantage of pressing that advantage? >> the other part is -- my instinct there's a power
analysis here, which is that fundamentally the senate is a sort of establishment institution and the establishment is on the side of conservatism fundamentally, and so there is this imbalance because the things -- as i'm speaking, there's 10,000 youth organizers in washington for the power shift congress, which is organized around climate change, and you don't hear a thing about them. they were in the streets toted outside the chamber of commerce with thousands of people yelling and no one pays attention to them. just like you were saying in the opening, and i think part of that has to do with the fact that when you look at united states senate, it's fundamentally, you know, in a deep way a kind of conservative body. people who are coming from the progressive perspective are kind of rolling a rock up a hill. they have strikes against them because the body itself is disposed to protect power and entrenched interest, and on the other side, it's much -- it's a much easier sort of agenda. >> what explains, though, the disconnect between the manifest strength of the tea party as a movement and the credit that they get in the beltway. i mean, you get 12 people standing in front of laguna beach, and there's the local news agency, though, ready to cover it. it's going to be the tea party
eth. that news agency didn't do anything wrong. people want to know about the tea party events, but they are man festally very, very small things. >> i can never quite figure out at what point the sort of vicious cycle got started, but it's clear that it's become -- it's like -- at a certain point you can never remember what kim kardashian is in the first place, but there she is, and you know her. whatever she does, then you got i feel like the tea party is sort of like that. there's this kind of self-fulfilling celebrity to them. sarah palin is a very sort of similar phenomenon, and i'm not sure how you break up that phenomenon. i mean, for all of us in the media, us included, it's a difficult thing because people do want to know what the tea party is up to, but the more coverage you give it, the more it seems like this massive thing, and i think bringing to
bear the fact that it is in many ways wained since the elections and it's an important point to hammer home. not just to people out there in the country, but to elected officials who still have a tremendously out-sized conception of its sort of numerical strength. >> chris hayes, washington editor of the nation magazine and msnbc contributor. thank you for being here, my friend. >> thanks a lot, rachel. coming up next, a big long story about kim kardashian. rs at or twice your money back. that's the smart beauty guarantee. 2-in-1's from pantene. healthy makes it happen. ♪ [ female announcer ] mini, meet berries.
sources, depending on which source you trust, are between several hundred and 2,000 people. still, look, it's a healthy crowd. looks like quite a healthy turnout. more than anywhere else, we think. unlike the sarah palin event, the turnout here in boca raton was not wildly swelled by counter protestors. why did this one event turn out a crowd when every one in the country was sort of a bust? well, it's because this one was headlined by reality tv star donald trump. perhaps you've heard once or twice or 1,000 times that mr.
trump has been flirting with the idea of running for president. his quasi campaign is built largely on a one issue platform, which is this. mr. trump, again, you may have heard, is a birther. big-time. he is generating headlines and lots of free publicity for the current season of his reality show by casting doubt on the citizenship of president obama. again, the result of this has been a lot of publicity for him, which maybe he monotizes somehow through his tv show rating. i can't make myself care long enough to know, but he has had lots of publicity, and maybe tralts to money for him, and that definitely translates to additional name recognition for him, which certainly translates to poll numbers. after making lots of noise on the birther issue, he is polling as a top tier number one or number two republican presidential contender. that has real republicans freaking out a little bit. last week house majority leader eric cantor criticized mr. trump by saying, "i don't think he is really serious. when we see a campaign launch odd the birther issue."
mr. trump responded thusly. >> i think it's a very bad thing for cantor to have done, because i will tell you, people love this issue. especially in the republican party. there's something to what we're saying. >> when you think of this odd publicity stunt candidacy, mr. trump is telling the truth about the birther thing. not about the substance of the issue. that's total nonsense, obviously. but he is telling the truth when he says that republicans love this as an issue. eric cantor might not like it, but republicans do, and those hawaiian born chickens are now coming home to roost for republicans. not just the embarrassingly successful candidacy of mr. trump, among likely republican voters. chickens are also coming home to roost here in the state of arizona. last week the same legislature that brought you sb 10-70, the papers please, law, that same legislature passed with a third bill. a bill that would keep off the ballot of the presidential candidate who does not provide arizona with a long form birth certificate to prove his or her citizenship. what is a long form birth certificate? it is a type of birth certificate that say the state of arizona does not even issue.
hasn't done so for years, which means that arizona in its infinite wisdom has just passed a bill through both houses of its legislature that would prevent future presidential candidates from arizona from appearing on that state's ballot. however, loophole. if you do not have that particular type of birth certificate that arizona doesn't even issue, you can supplement your weird prove your citizenship to arizona dossier with additional documents, such as a circumcision certificate. i am not making this up. that's what it says. a circumcision certificate. what's that you have there? a totally official printout of your birth record that everyone thinks of as a birth certificate? no, we arizonians do not accept that. but if you give us a document attesting to some -- sometimes religiously significant knife work in your down there area after birth, we'll take that. tonight only half an hour ago january brewer vetoed the birther bill saying that her veto letter, "i never imaged being presented with a bill that
could require candidates for president of the greatest and most powerful nation on earth to submit their early baptismal or circumcision certificates among other records to the arizona secretary of state." the legislature would need a two-thirds majority to override the governor's veto. based on the votes for the bill, republicans could easily do just that, which means it's likely that this bill could still become law. he told the ap that he had discussed this measure with donald trump personally, who liked it. he did not say whether trump liked the circumcision caveat specifically, but we have reached out to mr. trump's office to ask how he feels about that little bit at the end. increasing network capacity... and making a substantial investment to improve your wireless network experience. from a single phone call to the most advanced data download,
we're covering more people in more places than ever before in an effort to give you the best network possible. at&t. rethink possible. [ male announcer ] every day, thousands of people are choosing advil. here's one story. i'm keith baraka and i'm a fire fighter. it's an honor to be a fire fighter. my job involves life or death situations and it's very physically demanding. if i'm sore, i have a headache, i'm not at my best. i've tried store brands. advil just works for me. advil is my go to. it's my number one pain reliever. [ male announcer ] make the switch. take action. take advil. tall guy -- come on up here! so which razor do you use? the mach3 turbo. it's smooth, it's a close shave. i'm a creature of habit. it's a face-off! mach3 turbo vs. proglide. [ male announcer ] fusion proglide is engineered with gillette's thinnest blades ever so it glides for less tug and pull. it feels a lot better than the mach3. i'm sold. gimme that proglide. it's mine!
[ male announcer ] take the proglide challenge. and for enhanced glide, try new fusion proglide shave gel. and here's what we did today in homes all across america: we created the electricity that powered the alarm clocks and brewed the coffee. we heated the bathwater and gave kelly a cleaner ride to school. cooked the cube steaks and steamed the veggies. entertained dad, and mom, and a neighbor or two. kept watch on the house when they slept. and tomorrow we could do even more. we're cleaner, domestic, abundant and ready now. we're america's natural gas. the smarter power today. learn more at anga.us.
the great overreach of 2011 who is the most overreaching of all? yes, wisconsin governor's scott walker almost single-handedly galvanized the democratic base with his union-stripping crusade. yes, ohio's republican governor john kasic one-upped mr. walker by want just union-stripping, but union-stripping cops and firefighters specifically. then by screaming on camera about police officers he thinks are idiots. yes, florida's republican governor rick scott keeps coming up with big new categories of florida residents he wants to forcibly drug test. drug testing that happens to be provided by the governor's for profit health care company. but the dork horse in any tournament to determine the most
overreaching recent ly republican elected governor in 2010 has to be michigan's rick snyder. governor snyder not just union heavy stripping and trying to tax old people and poor people in order to give that money away to corporations, rick snyder signed the new law that lets his administration eliminate your voting rights at the local level. if you elected a mayor, a town council and any local officials in your town, the state under governor snyder will now decide if that election counts. they will decide if your town is allowed to keep your local election results or if they will overrule them and pose their
own. it's being called financial marshall law. his new powers that the governor took for hills. the republicans passed the bill in march and snyder signed it and used it. they just imposed it for the first time. guess where they're using it. guess what they're using it to do. guess. guess. >> announcer: this past year alone there's been a 67% spike in companies embracing the cloud-- big clouds, small ones, public, private, even hybrid. your data and apps must move easily and securely to reach many clouds, not just one. that's why the network that connects, protects, and lets your data move fearlessly through the clouds means more than ever. love those jeans. $175. ch-ching! excuse me? ever consider showing your customers what other stores charge for jeans?
um...no. when it comes to car insurance, progressive direct does. i saved hundreds when switching. that's a lot. the jeans are skinny. the savings... are fat. out there with a better way. now, that's progressive. can stop frequent heartburn before it begins? heartburn happens when stomach acid refluxes into the esophagus. prilosec otc uses a unique delayed-release system that protects the medicine as it passes through the stomach's tough acid. then it gets absorbed into the body, turning off many acid-producing pumps at the source. with just one pill a day, you get 24-hour heartburn protection all day and all night. prilosec otc. heartburn gone. power on.
the states are trying to make it harder to vote or to register to vote it this year. today with the stroke of a pen the great state of kansas became the gold standard in making it almost impossible to register to vote. kansas governor sam brownback, he used to be a senator. you may remember hem as one of the c street guys. now is he the governor of kansas, and today he signed into law a bill that requires kansas voters to prove their u.s. citizenship before registering to vote for the first time. to do that to register to vote, you are going to need to submit your birth certificate or a passport unless you have one of a list of much more obscure documents. back in february when this bill was first gathering steam, kevin miles, president of the kansas state conference of the naacp told us about this voter registration drive that had been held in the run-up to the 2008 election. voter registration drive was held at a park in wichita, kansas and was put together by a bunch of different community groups and in a few hours more
than 350 people got registered to vote. people who were just out at the park. imagine this happening if the folks grilling burgers and trying to get people registered were also asking for birth certificates and passports in order to get anybody signed up. loss of people get registered to vote at registration drives like that one in wichita or at the grocery store or post office. in other words, at places they tend to just be. running errands. doing other stuff. can't carrying their birth certificate or passport around with them. the kansas voter id bill here is the brainchild of a man who is standing here. his name is chris cobach. he is standing behind governor brownback. you may be familiar with his work, nonetheless. before chris was the secretary, he worked for the legal arm of the group, federation for american immigration reform, better known as fair, and when he was at fair, he worked on arizona's sb 1070 law, better known as the papers plea litigation -- legislation.
the federal government sued the state of arizona over the papers please law, and so far the state has been prevented from enforcing most of it. the same guy who wrote that law, the same guy who wrote arizona papers please law, the one that's all tied in court right now wants his new toughest in the nation voter id law from kansas to become a model for other states. he swears this is totally constitutional and stuff. right now the you need a passport or a birth certificate to register to vote provision, that goes into effect after the next presidential election. he says he is not giving up. he says he is going to keep trying to get that provision into effect sooner, whereby, if he is successful, just in time for president obama's re-election effort. it will become almost impossible to newly register to vote in kansas, and since newly registered voters tend to vote democratic, well, that will be right in time, won't it? joining us now is kansas democratic state representative ann mah who sat on the house
elections committee and who has been a vocal opponent of this voter id legislation. representative, thank you so much for your time tonight. snoo thank you for having me. >> i describe this as making it almost impossible to register to vote in kansas because of what we know about how voter registration drives work. they tend to intercept people when they are out doing their regular business. not thinking about registering to vote and they do so on the spur of the moment, which is precisely the sort of time when you wouldn't have your birth certificate or your passport on you. do you think that is the intent of the legislation, to make it harder to register? >> well, that's not what the secretary would say, but if you know how things work in kansas, you would know that that is exactly what's going to happen. grassroots registration will almost come to a halt, and even in the driver's license area where most registrations is done, we don't have documents on file for most of any of the people right now who are
renewing their driver's licenses, and so if you went into the driver's license bureau to register to vote, you won't be able to do that either. now, the secretary would tell you, oh, we're going to fix that, but it will be until probably 2019 before all renewing drivers have documents on file in the drivers bureau. snoo what do you think the practical impact will be if this does go into effect? what do you think will happen to voter registration patterns and, indeed, to voting patterns in kansas? >> well, the impact on registration would just be huge. as i mentioned, the efforts to do grassroots registration door to door, in the malls and grocery stores, as you said, that will just come to a halt. i mean, we'll be able to fill out 100 forms, but then you'll have to tell folks, well, hey, now you need to somehow get to the election office a copy of proof of citizenship. it will not be electronic for years. as you know, there's only one state in the union, georgia, that now has proof of citizenship in effect, but they have an electronic means to
check citizenship through your drivers record. kansas has nothing like that and will not have complete electronic availability for years to come. >> do you think that this new law is going to be challenged in court? >> absolutely, yes. i've already talked to several groups that realize this is a very bad law, and it has some -- holes big enough you could drive a truck through it. >> because of his history with the sb 1070 law and because he has been so overt and proud talking about this legislation as he says hopefully a model for other states, it -- he speaks with a lot of confidence about the idea that this will stand up in court if it is challenged. do you have a view and the people considering challenging of it, do they have a view of this as vulnerable in court? >> oh, absolutely. the secretary calls this bullet proof. he calls it a cadillac. i think it's a trojan horse. i think all you have to do is look at his record around the country of an inability to write a law that will pass muster.
i mean, there are small towns all over the place, hazleton, pennsylvania, farmers branch, texas, that are spending millions of dollars defending laws that he wrote that he claimed were constitutional there. what is sad is that, you know, the folks in kansas are pretty good folks, and we just want fair and safe elections, and maybe when the courts are done throwing out the big chunks of this law, we can have a real conversation about what it takes to have a commonsense safe election, but we'll have to, unfortunately, spend a lot of taxpayer money to get there. >> state representative ann mah of kansas. thank you for helping us to understand this tonight. i really appreciate your time. >> thank you for taking an interest. >> ed schultz and former chairman michael steel, appeared together on real-time with bill mahr on friday. did you see it? the results of their pairing on the tv machine was quite a lot of talk about it. seriously? the real story about real-time from ed schultz himself will come out after our show.
before ed starts a show, though, there is apparently a great threat to some conservatives in the form of paint, the war on art next. ] want a better way to track what you spend? pnc virtual wallet now comes with spending zone. it organizes all your spending, including your pnc debit card, credit card, and your bills. so you can view them by category... or by month. you can set a budget... and it'll even alert you when you're getting close to the amount you've set -- and when you've gone over. spending zone is built to help you keep better track of your spending. experience everything virtual wallet has to offer at pncvirtualwallet.com. pnc bank. for the achiever in you. tall guy -- come on up here! so which razor do you use? the mach3 turbo. it's smooth, it's a close shave. i'm a creature of habit. it's a face-off! mach3 turbo vs. proglide. [ male announcer ] fusion proglide is engineered with gillette's thinnest blades ever so it glides for less tug and pull. it feels a lot better than the mach3. i'm sold. gimme that proglide. it's mine! [ male announcer ] take the proglide challenge.
and for enhanced glide, try new fusion proglide shave gel. something that was drilled in me early on, you know, college is the place for you. it's my number one goal. ♪ students like me, who take these ap math and science classes and have these opportunities, this is where the american dream lies. when i write that book, you know, i plan to dedicate it to my school. ♪ those hopes and dreams that you have, you know, they're within reach. and i'm living proof.
>> there is a beautiful public beach in michigan that a specific group of rich people want to make into a beautiful exclusive beach. one small town, one really, really, really, really, really, really big republican government proposal. there goes the neighborhood. that's coming up. dn't see it co. i didn't realize i was drifting into the other lane. [ kim ] i was literally falling asleep at the wheel. it got my attention, telling me that i wasn't paying attention. i had no idea the guy in front of me had stopped short. but my car did. -my car did. -thankfully, my mercedes did. [ male announcer ] a world you can't predict... demands a car you can trust. the e-class. see your authorized mercedes-benz dealer for exceptional offers through mercedes-benz financial services.
an american artist were attacked at a modern art museum in france. they were physically attacked. according to the police, two people were seen trying to enter the museum with spray paint and a chisel. while they were stopped, a third person attacked the pieces of art with a hammer. the day before the attack, right-wing demonstrators, that denoun denounced the art in question as blasphemy. earlier this month in washington d.c., a painting was attacked as well. a woman screamed "this is evil" and started pounding on the painting with her fists. luckily, painting was protected by a layer of plexiglas. after going to blows with the object, the woman told investigators that the painting was "very homosexual." this follows another incident in october when a woman drove almost 700 miles from her home in montana to the loveland museum and gallery in loveland, colorado. she took out a crowbar and smashed the plexiglas off the
wall that was protecting a specific print and ripped the print to shreds. she later posted a ten-page blog post about her motivations, which i will spare you sufficed to say god told her too, blasphemy, that was evil, all the rest. this winter, speaker of the house, john boehner and republican congressman eric cantor demanded that the smithsonian remove a specific artwork from a show at the smithsonian. it was a piece by the late genius david vornorovich. it was about the aids crisis. it was about a film called "fire in the belly." the smithsonian faced up to the demands to remove the art and promptly caved. they removed the piece from the show. last month in maine, of course, the republican governor there ordered that a labor history mural be torn down and put into storage hidden from public view. prompting some other artists in maine to project that same mural on the walls of the state capitol. hey, what are you kids doing? we're putting the mural back up. amid this freak show international right wing outbreak of people attacking and
tearing down and hiding art, there is one detail in today's latest art attack story that heartens in the same way the maine mural projection does. that museum in france where andre serano's photographs were destroyed in that coordinated assault today, museum officials say they will reopen tomorrow in order to put the destroyed pieces still destroyed on display so that people can see the damage that was done to them. inanimate art cannot yell back, it cannot hit back. the only way art wins against force is if you can put the attack itself on display. see how that looks in the bright light of day. see how that holds up to history. [ kid ] it was the final play.
the big guy broke from the sidelines. and just like that, the goal was no longer the end zone... but the coveted blue bag. fumble! [ male announcer ] with so many real chocolate chips you'll never forget the moments that are crammed with joy, chips ahoy! it has up to 48 gigs of memory so it can hold work files, pictures, videos, music. whatever you need. and this is just the keyboard. all my stuff stays on the phone when i pull it off the lapdock. so it's a computer that's a phone. or a phone that's a computer, really, either way is correct. well, which is it, sir? you seem to be changing your story. [ male announcer ] the power of a computer. the portability of a smartphone. at&t presents the motorola atrix™ 4g. the world's most powerful smartphone. at&t. rethink possible.
[ male announcer ] for the things you can't wash, freshen it with febreze. febreze eliminates odors and leaves a light, fresh scent. it's a breath of fresh air. shaky! shaky! shaky! shaky! [ laughs ] shaky! shaky! [ gasps ] and if you named your own price on car insurance, you could be picking up this tab yourself. so get allstate. you could save some cash and be better protected from mayhem like me. [ dennis ] dollar for dollar nobody protects you from mayhem like allstate. my son and i never missed opening day. but with copd making it hard to breathe, i thought those days might be over. so my doctor prescribed symbicort. it helps significantly improve my lung function, starting within 5 minutes.
symbicort doesn't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. with symbicort, today i'm breathing better, and that means... game on! symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. it should not be taken more than twice a day. symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. [ whistle ] with copd, i thought i might miss out on my favorite tradition. now symbicort significantly improves my lung function, starting within 5 minutes. and that makes a difference in my breathing. today i'm back with my favorite team. ask your doctor about symbicort. i got my first prescription free. call or click to learn more. [ male announcer ] if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. if you start in chicago,
southeast, and then northeast. about 100 miles you get to a part of michigan, the twin cities. some times they call them the little twin cities because these twins are not nearly so big as the big twin cities in minnesota. they're also not nearly so the twin. this one, saint joseph, michigan, home to 8,500 or so people, nearly 90% white, got a per capita income of $33,000, something of a vacation town. a weekend get away for people in chicago. not purely that, but that is some of what it is. saint joseph. north across the saint joseph river, benton harbor, population not quite $11,000. benton harbor, approaching 90% african-american. saint joseph is nearly 90 white. per capita income, last estimation is less than a third of its twin across the river in saint joe. benton harbor per capita income is just over $10,000. which is very, very low. even the people who love benton harbor, michigan will tell you benton harbor has not got much.
when we talk about what happened to rust belt america, we talk about places like braddock, pennsylvania, or flint, michigan. we should talk about benton harborch because you can find every last social ill that goes along with industrial collapse, failing schools, crime, high unemployment, polluted land, corrupt government, the whole rusting away to misery and frustration and schedule 1 drugs deal of it. all of it. so, so benton harbor, michigan has not got much besides heartache. but it always had this one, wonderful, communal asset. one cherished jewel of the community. it's called gene clock park with a beach right on lake michigan for the people of benton harbor. the park was a gift off to the town in 1917 from john clock who founded the newspaper and served as mayor. they named the park after a daughter they lost as a baby, baby jeanne. they told the town when they gave the gift. the beach is yours. the drive is yours. the dunes are yours, all yours.
it is not so much a gift from my wife and myself, it's a gift from a little child. see to it that the park is the children's. and for nearly 100 years after that, jeanne clock park remained ape place that people went for baptisms and, and picnics, to pass a summer's night to teach their kids to swim, fish, build sand castles on the lake michigan shore. this beautiful park was their place. benton harbor had one other big important asset. jobs, jobs making whirlpool appliances, company town for whirlpool, they closed the last manufacturing plant in march. now mostly a call center there. also corporate offices for whirlpool where benton harbor people say they few hold of those corporate office jobs. as far back as the 1980s. whirlpool was looking for a way to get use out of old industrial land. one of the results, one of the ideas, a public/private redevelopment con cement. the idea to build a $500
million, 530-eric, jack nicklaus designed golf and residential development. some of the housing would be affordable as they say in public/private development ese. and some signature homes and beach style cottages and luxury condominiums. this new xanadu would start in saint joseph and reach over the river into benton harbor. along the way it would take jeanne clock park and remold it as a place of pristine greens and caddies and tee times with the occasional local school club sharing time there. as the people of benton harbor learned about this plan for their park, they were upset. and in 2006, they asked michigan's then democratic governor, they asked her for help. this was her office's reply. your concern regarding the proposed golf course in place of the jeanne clock park falls under the sole jurisdiction of your local government. this park is a local not state park. if you require further assistance with this issue you should contact your local
officials at city of beenton are bar to share your thoughts. that's the answer they got. talk to local officials in benton harbor. now i can tell you the people of beenton harbor who had so little they have not got even that. they have not got local officials who amount to anything. because benton harbor's local government is the first one to be essentially dissolved under michigan's emergency financial manager law. michigan messenger website friday posting this from the town's appointed emergency manager. now thereforebe it resolved as follows the, absent prior expressed written authorization and approval by the emergency manager, no city board, commission, or authority shall take any action for or on behalf of the city whatsoever other than call a meeting to order, approve of meeting minutes adjourn a meeting. this order shall be effective immediately. that's all you can do. mefting called to order. here we are at a meeting. meeting adjourned.
benton harbor's state appointed, state appointed emergency financial manager telling the elected city commission, that they can stay, that's about it. they can no longer do anything. state appointed manager is in complete control of benton harbor, michigan. if the state desires they could dissolve benton harbor completely. let its wealthier neighbor, saint joseph swallow it up. you don't have to ask benton harbor. the law that makes extrem measures possible, the michigan emergency manager law was sponsored by the state legislat legislator, al posholca, former staffer for the local congressman, fred upton, also a republican, fred upton is heir to the whirlpool fortune, that is his family money. his critics have called his first state bill financial martial law. on his website called the polsholca bill. you will want to know represents the district that includes
benton harbor. ran a mentoring program. knows the city well. in his backyard a very long time. he happens to be a former vice president for one of the entities involved in building luxury golf development set to remake benton harbor he served as a member of the nonprofit board of directors, until last year, same one behind the golf course. now the first town in michigan to feel the feteeth of the emergency manager, martial law, bill is benton harbor, entirely poor, in the district where he they're building the golf development he has spent years bringing into existence. now, right now the power of benton harbor elect owed officials has been take any way by the same people who had already been working to strip benton harbor of the one sieveic jewel that they had, the one thing they had left, their beautiful waterfront park. for the record, mr. posholca told us he does not have a
conflict. all of this has been for benton harbor's good. capital flows to places that are stable. i think we can all agree on that. you can get some idea of his vision for the new benton harbor from the ads for the golf development. >> the golf club at harbor shores is one reason to visit michigan's great southwest. but there is 100 reasons to stay. >> wait, stop. can we freeze it there. see the disclaimer at the bottom. images are not from harbor shore subdivisions. this is not real. don't call it benton harbor. this really isn't benton harbor. roll. >> have the time of your life. harbor shores. home of the 2012 senior pga championship. >> another slice of the vision, a sales pitch. this family is out enjoying the new walking trails that will be built. they're almost of course, a stock image, you can tell that becaus